A giant sugar cookie decorated like a Pepperoni Jalapeno Jelly Bean Pizza with Anchovies the Ninja Turtles would love. April Fools Day dessert, faux foods.

Fool Your Pizza Lover with this Fun Pizza Cookie

Tuesday was my son’s aide’s birthday. Considering J’s well known obsession with all things Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, I thought it would be fun to make a Pepperoni Jalapeno and Jelly Bean Pizza with Anchovies that would make Mikey drool (reference the Parasitica episode of the 2012 series).

TMNT Cookie Pizza

Or as J described it, “a silly pizza cookie”.

We started with a simple sugar cookie (recipe below, or use your own or even store bought) pressed into an 8″ cake pan.

sugar cookie in a cake pan

I cut the pieces before baking, which I knew would bake together in one whole cookie but be slightly scored so it will be easier for her to break into pieces to eat.

giant sugar cookie

After it baked and cooled we topped it with some red icing. I went store bought here because making red “red” icing is a pain to me.

spreading frosting on cookie

Coconut for the cheese.

adding the cheese, aka coconut

Candy coated chocolate candies (“M” side down): red for pepperoni and green for jalapenos.

putting pepperoni on thhe pizza

Jelly beans for the jelly beans and Swedish fish for the anchovies.

decorating candy pizza

Next, we needed a special way to present it to her.

I opened up a cereal box (because it was what I could find easily), covered the outside with butcher paper then folded it back into a box inside out and taped it so it would open like a pizza box.

cereal box turned into a pizza box

We made an order form to tape to the outside and a birthday message on the inside.

Cookie and Candy Pizza

This would be a fun thing to do with or for the kids for April Fool’s Day, or maybe a pizza or TMNT themed birthday party, or just for fun.

Egg Free Rolled Sugar Cookies

Meal type Dessert
From book Mrs. Fields Cookie Book: 100 Recipes from the Kitchen of Mrs. Fields
A simple egg-free rolled sugar cookie recipe.


  • 1 1/2 cup salted butter
  • 1 1/2 cup powdered sugar
  • 4 teaspoons vanilla extract
  • 3 cups all-purpose flour


In a medium bowl, cream butter. Add sugar, scraping bowl as needed, until smooth. Add vanilla and mix until creamy. Add flour. Gather dough into two balls, flatten into a disk and put in a plastic bag. Let rest in the refrigerator for 1 hour or until firm.
Preheat oven to 325 degrees. Roll out dough on a floured board and cut into desired shapes. Place on cookie sheet about 1/2 inch apart and bake about 15 minutes until just starting to turn brown.
Let cool completely and decorate with icing if desired.

Until next time, happy eating!

Don’t miss a post – subscribe to our mailing list

Email Format

15 thoughts on “Fool Your Pizza Lover with this Fun Pizza Cookie”

  1. This looks incredible! I’m drooling right now. Pinned and tweeted. We are so thrilled to have you at our party. Please stop by tonight at 7, so we can see your amazing projects. Lou Lou Girls

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badge